A personal collection of storiesWinstanley.biz
WINSTANLEY.bizStories worth telling

The beginning / Lancashire · London · 1970s–1998

Not Much Academic Potential

From a Rainford classroom to Wigan College and a PhD, by a route that was anything but straightforward.

Steven Winstanley · A personal account

I was thirteen when I came second in chemistry across my entire school year. Over 300 pupils, and I'd beaten almost everyone, including the bright kids in the top class.

I was in class six out of ten. The pupils expected to go to university were in classes one and two.

Eighteen years later, I completed a PhD in telecommunications engineering at the University of London.

Not quite the future anyone had in mind.

You see, I'd grown up in a working-class family in Rainford, Lancashire. My elder brothers had left school at fourteen, and I was expected to follow them into manual work.

At eleven, a teacher had already written in my school report:

“I do not feel that he is a boy with any great academic potential.”

She wasn't alone in thinking that.

And for quite a few years, it looked as though she might be right.

I left school at sixteen and spent three years working on farms. Later I found myself signing on the dole in plaster-covered clothes, a donkey jacket and hob-nailed boots.

University wasn't even on the horizon.

Yet somewhere between the farms, building sites, the dole office, fishing in a Lancashire pit and diving on German battleships in Scapa Flow, life took a rather unexpected turn.

It wasn't some grand plan to prove my teachers wrong.

In truth, I had no plan at all.

But that's where the story begins.

Knowing your place

There were ten classes in each year at Rainford High School, thirty to thirty-five pupils in a class. You didn't need anyone to explain the pecking order. The children in classes one and two might go to university. I started in class seven and worked my way up to six. Five classes still above me; I didn't trouble them much.

My chemistry mark of 92 per cent came in 1980. First in my class, second in the whole year. You can see it on the report, alongside less enthusiastic remarks about my concentration and maturity. It wasn't the only subject I could do well in. Science and technical drawing suited me. English literature was a different matter entirely.

Rainford High School report showing 92 per cent in chemistry
The 1980 school report. First in class, second in the whole year.

The teachers weren't imagining my lack of interest. By fifteen, I had largely switched off. A later report recorded perfect attendance — 182 sessions out of 182 — which proves I was in the building, if nothing else.

I had an unfortunate encounter with the woodwork teacher after waving at him through an open window. He strapped me. I thought it was unfair, and when I had to choose between woodwork and metalwork, metalwork won. Not the most sophisticated method of choosing a subject, but it settled the matter.

We lived on the edge of Rainford. From the age of about five I could be out all day, roaming the woods, wheat fields, grassland and farm tracks. I'd leave home in the morning and return before dark. There was room to wander, and it rarely occurred to me that the countryside was anything other than somewhere I was free to explore.

Away from school I had somewhere better to be. At the British Legion's Siding Lane pit in Rainford, I'd spend evenings and weekends fishing for roach, bream, tench and carp. Sometimes the float went under; often it didn't. What interested me as much as catching fish was the world I couldn't see beneath them.

Jacques Cousteau was on the television exploring wrecks and swimming through clear blue water. I was at a Lancashire fishing pit, wondering what might be down there. It seemed a reasonable place to start.

The television after the pub

From thirteen to sixteen I had a milk round four mornings a week. I was up at half past three, started at four and finished around half seven. I was tired in the mornings, but Saturdays meant double milk and pay that was much better than my friends got from their paper rounds.

Some of that money bought my fishing tackle. Some went on the pub — I'd started drinking at thirteen, and the wages I collected on Saturday morning could be gone by Sunday night. I won't pretend that was a sensible financial arrangement.

There's a peculiar memory from those years that has stayed with me. I'd come home from the pub, sometimes drunk, switch on the television and find an Open University programme. It would be halfway through a course, with a lecturer talking about something so advanced I hadn't a hope of following it. No introduction, no easing you in. Just straight into the difficult stuff.

I'd sit and listen anyway.

There were some clever people in the world, I thought. They seemed to be talking a language I hadn't been taught. I had no idea that university would ever have anything to do with me.

Three years on the farms

Farming ran through my mother's family. It was how my parents met: my father worked on her family's farm before moving into construction and, later, loading glass lorries at Pilkingtons. So when I left school at sixteen, working on the land wasn't some unusual detour.

I spent about three years at Mossborough Hall Farm in Rainford, from sixteen to nineteen. Those weren't three years spent waiting to go to university. As far as I knew, this was my working life. Around nineteen I also worked for Dave Pope at Melling Mount Farm in Maghull.

The other side of the counter

Then I was made redundant. In the North West in those years, finding yourself without work was hardly unusual. That didn't make it any easier. When you'd always been expected to earn your living, unemployment could make you feel that you weren't worth much at all.

I can still see the dole office. A dusty, dirty room, bare walls, not a decoration in sight. A long counter ran across the front, with no glass screen separating us from the staff. Behind the women dealing with the queues were other people busy at their desks. They had jobs. I was standing on the other side, and had no idea how someone like me was ever supposed to get a job in an office.

There were at least five queues, mostly men. Among them were colliers from the recently closed pits: hard, working men who'd spent their lives earning a wage, now lining up for what I remember as about £15 a week. Most of us were in working clothes. A bit of casual labour might bring in a few extra pounds, but it wasn't enough to feed a family.

Every fortnight I'd join them, sometimes in plaster-covered clothes, a donkey jacket and hobnailed boots from my work as a plasterer's labourer. Eventually I'd reach the counter. The woman would ask the same question: “In the last two weeks, have you worked?”

“No.”

The plaster on my clothes wasn't exactly subtle. Sometimes friends were taken aside, asked again, and shown photographs of themselves working. Their benefit would stop. The odd bit of work hadn't been enough to live on; losing the benefit made a bad situation worse. You could see the office staff getting on with their day while the rest of us queued to answer a question nobody particularly wanted to hear.

The things you did to get by

There were other ways of making a bit of money. I spent time scuba diving at Eccleston Delph near Chorley, where cars had been dumped in the quarry. Some were Ford Fiesta XR2s, Escort XR3is and Rover 3500s. I'd recover alloy wheels, engines, gearboxes and other useful parts, clean them up and sell them to people who wanted to improve their own cars. An unusual sideline, admittedly, but I knew what the parts were and there were people who wanted them.

I also managed my first holiday abroad, to Crete. There were still moments of freedom and fun in those years. But underneath it was the question of where the next proper job might come from.

If you'd told me then that I'd spend years at university and end up with a doctorate, I doubt I'd have taken you seriously. I was having enough trouble working out what to do next week.

Two weeks to learn to dive

Diving had taken hold of me. My father worked at Pilkington, which meant I was allowed to join the company's sub-aqua club. In 1984, aged seventeen, I had saved enough from work to buy my own kit. A club member asked whether I fancied going to Scapa Flow to dive the German High Seas Fleet.

Of course I did.

The trip was leaving in two weeks. There was just the slight problem that I hadn't learned to scuba dive.

We trained in the little pool at Boundary Road Baths in St Helens. The deep end was ninety centimetres. At the weekend I took my new drysuit and other equipment to Eccleston Delph. The water was cold and dark, visibility perhaps half a metre. With the hood, gloves and all that neoprene, I felt claustrophobic for the first and only time I can remember. I managed two shallow dives, neither beyond five metres.

Then we travelled to Orkney.

My third open-water dive was to thirty-three metres, on the wreck of the Dresden, with the club's training officer. We stayed down long enough to require decompression stops. At nine metres he ran out of air, and we began sharing my single regulator. At six metres, with thirty seconds of the stop remaining, mine ran out as well. We surfaced with no breathing gas left.

I was seventeen. I'd done three open-water dives. There are probably better ways of learning.

We went on to dive most of the battleship wrecks, operating from the club's small inflatable boats. I eventually became the club's next training officer, teaching members who worked at Pilkington and were generally rather better off than I was. There's a much longer story to tell about that trip, but for now it's enough to say that I survived my introduction to the underwater world — and wanted more.

Wigan

By 1987 I was at Wigan College of Technology studying electronics, computing and communications. I can't point to one moment when everything changed. What I remember is that the subjects interested me. For once, putting in the work didn't seem quite so much like punishment.

One of my tutors, Tom Austin, could see I was capable of more than I was being asked to do. He encouraged me to take extra higher-level subjects, attend evening classes and consider university. The same boy who'd listened in bewilderment to Open University broadcasts was now staying late to study, because he wanted to.

Tom also arranged a summer placement with British Gas North Western, which I undertook in 1990 while at university. That came later. At Wigan, what mattered first was that somebody was taking my abilities seriously.

The National Diploma results were fifteen distinctions and three merits, alongside five additional higher-level units. Tom wrote that it was the best National Diploma the college had issued. He even predicted I would come out of Queen Mary College with a first-class honours degree. I kept the report.

Tom Austin handwritten comments in Wigan College diploma report
Tom Austin’s assessment of my National Diploma. I kept this report too.

There was a problem, naturally. My school English qualification still counted against me. Liverpool and UMIST wouldn't accept me on that basis, while an interview at Southampton involved Laplace transforms, Fourier analysis and circuit analysis. I remember feeling out of my depth. In some ways, I was back watching the Open University, only now the lecturer was asking me the questions.

Queen Mary and Westfield College in London offered me a place. In 1989 I went.

Euston

I arrived in London at Euston in 1989. After the fields and farm tracks around Rainford, it was bewildering. The noise, the traffic, the dirt and the smell seemed to be everywhere. I'd come south to take up a place at university, but my first impression was that I'd landed somewhere I didn't understand.

Up North, I was used to talking to anybody. A few words with a stranger were perfectly ordinary. I tried the same in London and got blank looks in return. Some seemed to think I was mad. I wasn't asking for a life story. A reply would have been a start.

Back in Rainford, I could spend a whole day wandering from one field to another and feel at home. At Euston, surrounded by people, I had never felt quite so far from it. I had worked on farms, on building sites and in a world where university was for somebody else. Now I was supposed to belong here. It was a rather larger step than the train journey suggested.

Further afield

The university years took me well beyond London. In 1990 I had a placement with British Gas North Western, working in Instrumentation and Communications at Partington, near Manchester. That was familiar country, at least. Spain was something else.

I stayed with a Spanish family, getting to know their daily life rather than simply passing through. I discovered the Basque Country, and on a visit to a relative of theirs in Salas, near Oviedo, I encountered the Picos de Europa for the first time. Those mountains stayed in my mind. I returned to Spain in 1991, travelling through Vitoria, Zarautz and San Sebastián, and even running with the bulls in Pamplona. It was a rather different education from sitting in a lecture theatre.

What I remember most is being let into the ordinary life of another country — its people, conversations and customs. I came away wanting to see more, and to return. The places I'd known as a boy were no longer the limits of my world.

The road into research

In 1992 I spent the summer working at AscomTech in Bern, Switzerland. The work introduced me to queueing theory applied to teletraffic engineering: the mathematics of what happens when more calls or data arrive than a communications system can deal with at once. Waiting, congestion, capacity — problems that sound mundane until you realise how much of a network depends on getting them right.

That summer mattered. Ascom gave me a foothold in the subject that would eventually lead into my PhD. Away from work, Switzerland had its own attractions. I learned to ski, spent time hiking in the Bernese Oberland and tried paragliding. I was getting rather used to the idea that a summer could take me somewhere completely new.

My final-year project brought me into European telecommunications research through the RACE Broadband Access Facilities programme. After completing my engineering degree at Queen Mary in 1993, I stayed on to investigate quality of service over Asynchronous Transfer Mode (ATM) networks. Queueing theory was no longer something I'd encountered during a summer job: it had become one of the tools of my research.

That work continued through European RACE and ACTS research projects, working with people across the continent. In November 1998 I completed my PhD in telecommunications engineering and left university for Roke Manor Research.

Wigan College had once written a feature about me called Not to Be a Farmer's Boy. A curious title, given that I'd already spent three years working on farms. Somewhere in my papers it sits alongside those old school reports. One describes a boy without much academic potential. The other celebrates a student whose tutor thought he could go a long way.

The original Wigan College article Not to Be a Farmer’s Boy
The Wigan College feature, Not to Be a Farmer’s Boy.

I still have them both.

When I left university, I'd spent most of my adult life getting there by a route nobody, least of all me, had mapped out. But studying had never been the whole of my life. There were wrecks to dive, places to visit, people to meet, and quite a few adventures I hadn't yet seen coming.

Written from my own recollections and surviving school and college reports. This is a draft for editorial review.

Read another story

975 miles. One bicycle.

In 2015, I set off from Land’s End with a bike, a route and a great many miles ahead.

Read the story →